+- MacResource (https://forums.macresource.com)
+-- Forum: My Category (https://forums.macresource.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: 'Friendly' Political Ranting (https://forums.macresource.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=6)
+--- Thread: Had the Confederate Won the War ... (/showthread.php?tid=65153)
Re: Had the Confederate Won the War ... - Doc - 10-29-2008
Who would they have sided with in WWII?
Re: Had the Confederate Won the War ... - Gutenberg - 10-29-2008
I don't think a CSA would have been powerful enough to make a difference in World War II.
Re: Had the Confederate Won the War ... - mikeylikesit - 10-30-2008
I'd be Canadian. The older generations would never have migrated south.
Re: Had the Confederate Won the War ... - mikeylikesit - 10-30-2008
Can you imagine the leaders of the South attempting to govern hostile cities of the North? New England would probably have seceded and a few northern states might have petitioned to become Provinces of Canada.
They'd have to let them go now that the principal had been upheld, would they not?
Re: Had the Confederate Won the War ... - karsen - 10-30-2008
Doc wrote:
Who would they have sided with in WWII?
Many ex-Confederates and southerners fought in WWI against the Germans.
Re: Had the Confederate Won the War ... - cbelt3 - 10-30-2008
Great^6 grandpa would have died instead of living and fathering my ancestors. So i would not be here.
Re: Had the Confederate Won the War ... - the_poochies - 10-30-2008
Perhaps US factories wouldn't have moved to Mexico, China and India if we staffed them with slaves. I'm sure if Wal-Mart were around in 1861 we'd know which side they'd be on :wink:
Re: Had the Confederate Won the War ... - mikeylikesit - 10-31-2008
karsen wrote:
[quote=Doc]
Who would they have sided with in WWII?
Many ex-Confederates and southerners fought in WWI against the Germans.
Southerners have always been a larger than average population in our military, here are any number of reasons for this maybe the single largest being economic. We entered WWI more than 50 years after the Civil War ended, I doubt they were taking in 70-year old ex-Confederates.
Re: Had the Confederate Won the War ... - Doc - 10-31-2008
I meant WWII, not WWI.
There's good reason to believe that the Kaiser would have been defeated with or without us.
Not so with Hitler's Germany.
Would they sit out international conflicts? Would they be imperialists? Would internal conflicts with abolitionists lead to a second American Revolution? Would New England have seceded or joined the Canadian Confederacy?
Re: Had the Confederate Won the War ... - mikeylikesit - 10-31-2008
The Canadian border today might run just north of the Mason/Dixon line.