+- MacResource (https://forums.macresource.com)
+-- Forum: My Category (https://forums.macresource.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: Tips and Deals (https://forums.macresource.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Thread: Musicians you just don't get (/showthread.php?tid=128734)
Musicians you just don't get - DeusxMac - 12-14-2011
Strictly speaking about musical abilities, among the famous and lauded pop/rock/folk/country musicians (performers or bands), are there any you just cannot understand what all the fuss is/was about?
I'll start the ball rolling (an incur the wrath of their faithful, no doubt) with Bob Dylan and Johnny Cash.
If you didn't know who was performing (a tough assignment, I know,) this would verge on the un-listenable, especially their "harmonies":
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2aSLMEKl8E4
Re: Musicians you just don't get - cbelt3 - 12-14-2011
Oh, that's EASY.
Pretty much ANY teenybopper 'musician'. Especially ones with non Alpha characters in their names. Blech.
Re: Musicians you just don't get - the_poochies - 12-14-2011
Sure, and this is probably heretical to most people. I never understood why Bob Dylan, Frank Zappa and Bruce Springsteen were so fawned over by the music press. I like a few of their songs, but to me, Dylan has a voice like nails on a chalkboard and sung bland tunes that ended up becoming overloaded with many of the musical excesses and self-absorption of the 1970s. Frank Zappa....nope, I don't get it at all. Unlistenable. I like Bruce Springsteen as a person and a citizen, but his music is standard NJ bar band schlock. He just got discovered at the right time by the right person.
I enjoyed the Beach Boys' Pet Sounds but would never consider it a masterpiece.
Feel free to call me a cretin (which is far more enjoyable to me, IMHO).
Re: Musicians you just don't get - DRR - 12-14-2011
Bob Dylan was a great songwriter but a terrible singer.
Same with Neil Young, same with Kurt Cobain. Not that they are not all brilliant in their own right.
My current ??? is Bon Iver. Everyone seems to love them but I don't see the appeal.
Re: Musicians you just don't get - DeusxMac - 12-14-2011
the_poochies wrote:
I never understood why... Bruce Springsteen...so fawned over by the music press. I like Bruce Springsteen as a person and a citizen, but his music is standard NJ bar band schlock.
Thank you!
He's on my list too.
Re: Musicians you just don't get - edgarbc1 - 12-14-2011
Micheal Buble
Celtic Women
from those PBS specials around membership drives
from the pantheon of rock:
many of the 80s Hair Bands
Poison
Ratt
for example
also (tho i may bear the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune for such blasphemy....)
Steely Dan
i know many who dont like bands i like for example
Grateful Dead
Phish
Fishbone
they are common on the "i just dont get them" circuit
Re: Musicians you just don't get - decay - 12-14-2011
Mumford & Sons - a freakin' Grammy?
Re: Musicians you just don't get - mikebw - 12-14-2011
DeusxMac wrote:
[quote=the_poochies]
I never understood why... Bruce Springsteen...so fawned over by the music press. I like Bruce Springsteen as a person and a citizen, but his music is standard NJ bar band schlock.
Thank you!
He's on my list too.
#1 on my list as well. "The Boss" ? Whatever.
Re: Musicians you just don't get - the_poochies - 12-14-2011
DeusxMac wrote:
[quote=the_poochies]
I never understood why... Bruce Springsteen...so fawned over by the music press. I like Bruce Springsteen as a person and a citizen, but his music is standard NJ bar band schlock.
Thank you!
He's on my list too.
This is especially odd considering I am a lifelong NJ resident.
Re: Musicians you just don't get - DRR - 12-14-2011
Really? I like Springsteen. To each his own.