Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
The compromise.
#1
As I expected, the Obama administration is revising their HHA ruling dealing with birth control coverage. They are using (like I thought they would) a flavor of the Hawaiian compromise.

Within minutes of announcing the change in policy, the White House began rolling out endorsements from some Catholic organizations, including the Catholic Health Association and Catholics United. Planned Parenthood also applauded the action.

and

"My first job in Chicago was working with Catholic parishes in poor neighborhoods, and my salary was funded by a grant from an arm of the Catholic Church," Obama said. "And I saw that local churches often did more good for a community than a government program ever could, so I know how important the work that faith-based organizations do and how much impact they can have in their communities.

I also know that some religious institutions -- particularly those affiliated with the Catholic Church -- have a religious objection to directly providing insurance that covers contraceptive services for their employees."

On the other hand, he cited "the more cynical desire on the part of some to make this into a political football."

"I understand some folks in Washington may want to treat this as another political wedge issue, but it shouldn't be," he said. "I certainly never saw it that way."


I agree with Obama and those organizations in terms of finding a way through this. I disagree with those politicians and other Catholic leaders who seem to be itching to make more political hay of this.

There. I have liberals AND conservatives disagreeing with me now Smile
Reply
#2
Bonehead move by the administration to piss off mainstream Catholics before figuring out this compromise. Now Republicans get to claim (legitimately) a victory, and President Obama has to eat crow.
Reply
#3
Welcome to REAL politics.. the art of the deal. It's an arm's length bit of three card monte that lets women get the same services, but lets the Churches claim they're not part of it.

Well done, Mr. President.

Now can we talk about what's important ?
Reply
#4
This is a non-issue that would never have made the papers if the election wasn't nigh.
Reply
#5
cbelt3 wrote:
Welcome to REAL politics.. the art of the deal. It's an arm's length bit of three card monte that lets women get the same services, but lets the Churches claim they're not part of it.

Well done, Mr. President.

Now can we talk about what's important ?

Exactly.
Reply
#6
>>Bonehead move by the administration to piss off mainstream Catholics

In another thread it was cited that there is almost universal ignorance of the ban on birth control among the parishioners. don't confuse the politics of the leadership of the church with that of the followers. we've seen this in start relief on a certain issue that can't be left alone.
Reply
#7
FWIW, matt, we're not ignorANT of the stricture. We ignorE it.
Reply
#8
cbelt3 wrote:
Welcome to REAL politics.. the art of the deal. It's an arm's length bit of three card monte that lets women get the same services, but lets the Churches claim they're not part of it.

Well done, Mr. President.

Now can we talk about what's important ?

Don't blame that brouhaha on the President, Belty. Not his fault at all. He deserves credit for working it out.
Reply
#9
I expect many more of these "working it outs" between now and November.












I'm gonna miss Michelle.
Reply
#10
Gutenberg wrote:
[quote=cbelt3]
Welcome to REAL politics.. the art of the deal. It's an arm's length bit of three card monte that lets women get the same services, but lets the Churches claim they're not part of it.

Well done, Mr. President.

Now can we talk about what's important ?

Don't blame that brouhaha on the President, Belty. Not his fault at all. He deserves credit for working it out.
I disagree. He made the initial decision to not do the compromise, even though key advisers like Vice President Biden and then Bill Dailey pointed out the political problems.

For those who have a problem with the initial decision, he gets some measure of blame for doing that. He also gets credit for working it out. (Parenthetically, I DO realize that there are still some issues to be worked out in the implementation... it will be an imperfect solution)
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)