Need GPS recs: iPhone GPS app vs. standalone GPS

[pinkoos]

One of the biggest things I lost when switching from Android to iPhone is Google's awesome, built-in and free GPS.

So, I'm in the market for a GPS and am confused as to whether I should go for an iPhone app vs. a standalone model.

Perusing the options they have for standalone models at Costco the other day left me dazed and confused. What are the things I should be looking for? What are "must have" features and what things are just fluff?

In terms of iPhone GPS apps, who are the big players? I think I saw mention of one the other day called "MotionX" or something like that. I didn't really look into the details but do remember it being relatively cheap.

Anyway, any advice pointing me in one direction or the other would be appreciated. And, once pointed, any specific model/app recs would be great.

By the way, I have a 4S, 64GB if that matters.

[graylocks]

i have both an iPhone and a Garmin stand alone. for just running around town the iPhone is sufficient: i use the NavFree app and the MapQuest 4 Mobile app.

for long trips i prefer to set up the garmin as i simply don't want my iPhone tied up doing navigation, the Garmin screen is larger (i think i have a 1390 or something like that) and i find the garmin easier to find what i'm looking for in.

i think anything besides navigation and phone book on steroids is fluff (mp3 player, photos) but you'd be hard put to find a gps unit that simple. voices streets is a given these days. i have free lifetime traffic which is nice but not essential to me especially since i found apps for that.

[SDGuy]

Unless things have changed, if I recall, most phone-based GPS options rely on downloading maps as needed - if you happen to be without cell coverage, you no longer have maps. For most everyday commuting, this is fine - but if you plan on roadtrips away from civilization, you should bear this in mind.

For standalone GPS units, TomTom & Garmin are really the only names to consider. Lifetime map updates and lifetime traffic are de rigueur. With all the sales going on for the holidays, you should be able to nab one for less than $150 any day of the week, right around $100-$125 if you really dig and shop around...

[graylocks]

NavFree downloads the map info;uses 1.9 GB. don't know about MapQuest 4Mobile.

[Spiff]

I second Mapquest 4 mobile for the iPhone. Yes, it will tie up your phone, you will need to have it plugged in constantly as it's a huge drain and the phone will get HOT as it's constantly processing information.

I like the Garmin series of GPS. Ignore Bluetooth capabilities as the voice commands and phone sync don't work in a car with road noise. Just doesn't. Don't argue.

https://buy.garmin.com/shop/shop.do?cID=401&pID=97515

My wife has this series (the model above this with Bluetooth capabilities. A waste of $). I really like it a lot. Don't bother with the traffic mode, does a lousy job of predicting traffic. However, it is a bit pricey. OTherwise, the 2400 series GPSs look good as well, just not as flashy. Doing some research, looks like this is as simple as it gets!

https://buy.garmin.com/shop/shop.do?cID=401&pID=100840

my 2 cents worth...

[pinkoos]

We had a pretty bad experience with a Garmin while on our summer trip to the Canadian Rockies:

http://forums.macresource.com/read.php?1...sg-1169120

But, admittedly, we didn't have the manual and I really didn't have time to spend trying to figure it out. I was hoping that it would be pretty intuitive, but it wasn't. I'm sure it was a dated, el cheapo model provided by the rental company so maybe the ones available now and the ones being rec'd by you guys are much improved.

[davester]

I use ALK CoPilot Live for a GPS app that has all the maps built into the phone and so works where there is no network, and I use MotionX GPS Drive if my entire trip will be in an area where I've got good cell coverage. Both are cheap and good. I've also heard good things about mapquest.

Bear in mind that the GPS receiver in any kind of phone is a lot less powerful than the receiver in a dedicated GPS unit, so the accuracy and position updating frequency are always going to be poorer with a phone.

[datbeme]

It would probably be most helpful to have both. A standalone unit is nice to have at times (when you are without cellular data or when you just don't want to tie up your phone), but if I had to pick, I'd prefer to have it in my phone. It's always with me, and maybe it's because my standalone unit is a few years old, but I find the interface much easier to work with when it comes to inputing addresses (cutting and pasting, links from emails and google searches or direct access to addresses of contacts.

Not saying it's the be all, end all, but you should at least try MotionX. The app is only $0.99 and it includes a 30 day trial. If you like it, grab the year of guidance which is on sale for $9.99 right now.

I did the trial of the latest Garmin app, and I did like the driving and prompts more than the MotionX Drive (looks to be similar to their current standalone units), but the data entry, manipulation and special features weren't as good as MotionX's. Was going to purchase it anyway but the price jumped from an introductory $15 to the standard $30 before I made up my mind.

[Grateful11]

graylocks wrote:
i have both an iPhone and a Garmin stand alone. for just running around town the iPhone is sufficient: i use the NavFree app and the MapQuest 4 Mobile app.

for long trips i prefer to set up the garmin as i simply don't want my iPhone tied up doing navigation, the Garmin screen is larger (i think i have a 1390 or something like that) and i find the garmin easier to find what i'm looking for in.

i think anything besides navigation and phone book on steroids is fluff (mp3 player, photos) but you'd be hard put to find a gps unit that simple. voices streets is a given these days. i have free lifetime traffic which is nice but not essential to me especially since i found apps for that.

Same here! iPhone 4 and a Garmin 255W

[mattkime]

I've been very happy with Navigon on my iphone but i use it very rarely since i live in nyc and rarely drive.