02-20-2007, 05:17 PM
Okay, let's run down the main characters:
Adama: No chance. He pre-dates the "human" Cylons, and he has kids.
Tigh: See Adama, minus the kids. And it would ruin the show's best character. Tigh's wife (RIP) would have been perfect, though.
Apollo: Nope, Adama knows he had a kid, and it's Lee.
Starbuck: The leading contender... despite the fact that she's the most human character on the show, and it'd be a huge shark-jump if she's a Cylon.
Laura: Doubtful. Her age also pre-dates the human Cylons, and she wouldn't have gotten cancer, would she?
Helo: Uh, no. That'd make the Helo-Sharon story really stupid.
Tyrol: Nope. He's had a kid. Ditto for Cally.
Sharon: She's a Cylon. Whoops--we knew that already.
Anders: Probably not, but it'd be an interesting twist.
Gaeta: Maybe. It'd explain why he's BSG's Data (besides the fact that Ron Moore needed a Data on the bridge do give all the exposition).
Dee: Entirely possible. Don't know what Xena did to offend her, though.
Baltar: Too anti-climax, among many other reasons. Even so, might be him.
Zarek: Now this would be interesting.
Personally, I'd love it if one of the "secret" Cylons turned out to be Dirk Benedict...
Adama: No chance. He pre-dates the "human" Cylons, and he has kids.
Tigh: See Adama, minus the kids. And it would ruin the show's best character. Tigh's wife (RIP) would have been perfect, though.
Apollo: Nope, Adama knows he had a kid, and it's Lee.
Starbuck: The leading contender... despite the fact that she's the most human character on the show, and it'd be a huge shark-jump if she's a Cylon.
Laura: Doubtful. Her age also pre-dates the human Cylons, and she wouldn't have gotten cancer, would she?
Helo: Uh, no. That'd make the Helo-Sharon story really stupid.
Tyrol: Nope. He's had a kid. Ditto for Cally.
Sharon: She's a Cylon. Whoops--we knew that already.
Anders: Probably not, but it'd be an interesting twist.
Gaeta: Maybe. It'd explain why he's BSG's Data (besides the fact that Ron Moore needed a Data on the bridge do give all the exposition).
Dee: Entirely possible. Don't know what Xena did to offend her, though.
Baltar: Too anti-climax, among many other reasons. Even so, might be him.
Zarek: Now this would be interesting.
Personally, I'd love it if one of the "secret" Cylons turned out to be Dirk Benedict...